Score Big with Retention: Measuring Your Insurance Agency's "Real" Success

Boost your insurance agency's retention like a winning baseball team! Learn 3 ways to measure "real retention" and strategies to keep clients happy and loyal.

3 months ago   •   2 min read

By The ReFocus Team
Photo by Jose Francisco Morales / Unsplash

Building a successful independent insurance agency takes a lot of dedication. Just like a baseball team aiming for a championship, you need to attract new clients (think of them as "recruiting players") and provide exceptional service. However, focusing solely on new acquisitions is not sufficient.

Retention, or keeping your existing clients happy and loyal, is equally crucial. So, how do you determine how well your agency performs in this vital area? Fortunately, there are ways to measure your "real retention," which gives valuable insights to strengthen your team and secure long-term success.

Understanding the "Stats": Three Levels of Retention Measurement

As an analogy, imagine your agency as a baseball team. Measuring retention can be compared to tracking different aspects of the game.

  • At the policy level, it's like counting individual players who renew their policies. Did they "stay on the team" or "strike out" by switching to another agency?
  • On the account level, consider each client as a player and all their policies as their equipment. Did a client renew all their policies with you, or did they "keep some bats but ditch the gloves" by renewing only certain ones?
  • Finally, at the revenue level, it's like keeping score for the team. Did you maintain or increase revenue from renewed policies, even if some clients had fewer policies?

While each level is valuable, relying solely on any of them doesn't tell the whole story. Combining policy and account-level retention paints a more accurate picture akin to tracking individual player performance and overall teamwork. This "real retention" reveals how effectively you retain clients and keep your agency flourishing.

The Benefit of Measuring and Understanding "Real Retention"

By measuring your "real retention," you gain valuable insights into your agency's performance. This information lets you:

  • Identify areas of success: See which client segments and policy types showcase strong retention, indicating areas where your agency excels.
  • Pinpoint improvement opportunities: Recognize areas with lower retention, allowing you to tailor strategies to improve client satisfaction and loyalty in those segments.
  • Set informed goals: Use real retention data to establish attainable and impactful goals for your agency's growth and development.
  • Make data-driven decisions: Back your decisions with reliable data, ensuring your strategies are rooted in facts and tailored to improve your agency's "win rate."

Building a Winning Team: Strategies for Improving Retention

Once you understand your "real retention" score, you can implement strategies to enhance your team's performance:

  • Proactive communication: Regularly connect with your clients, offer personalized service, and address their concerns promptly. This builds trust and fosters a sense of valued partnership.
  • Review and adjust coverages: Conduct regular policy reviews with clients, ensuring their coverage remains appropriate as their needs evolve. This demonstrates your commitment to their well-being.
  • Personalized and targeted communication: Segment your client base and tailor communication strategies to their specific needs and interests. This shows you value them as individuals, not just numbers.
  • Invest in client relationships: Foster genuine connections with your clients. Remember, people buy from people they like and trust.

Conclusion: The Winning Formula for Long-Term Success

Building a thriving insurance agency requires a multi-pronged approach. While attracting new clients is essential, prioritizing "real retention" ensures long-term success. By measuring and analyzing your agency's performance using a combination of policy and account-level data, you gain valuable insights to improve client satisfaction and loyalty. Implementing targeted strategies based on these insights empowers your team to become a winning force in the insurance market, season after season.

Spread the word

Keep reading